Youth sports injuries: A call to arms
March 2, 2004
"It's an epidemic," Remia
says. "If a kid has pain, and it's not going away,
it's not normal."
By Nick Sortal, Sun-Sentinel , originally published
in the Sun-Sentinel on Feb. 8, 2004
The trophies get bigger, the players start younger
and the seasons run year-round. And children pay a price
much higher than just sweat.
Youth sports injuries are increasing in epidemic numbers.
"Some days our waiting room looks like a pediatrician's
office," says Dr. Robert Sheinberg of the South
Florida Institute of Sports Medicine. He specializes
in foot and ankle injuries.
Most of the time it's a sprain or a ligament injury,
and Sheinberg says some Mondays he'll have up to 10
new adolescent patients, banged-up from weekend games.
"It's like boom-boom-boom, one after the other,"
he says. He usually prescribes a four-letter word to
the athletes -- rest -- in hopes that some down time
will prevent a need for surgery.
A couple of miles away from Sheinberg's Weston office,
Dr. Len Remia at the Cleveland Clinic Hospital examines
arms of baseball players worn out from overactivity,
as well as afflictions from other sports. Teenage pitchers
are undergoing elbow reconstruction "Tommy John"
surgery four times as often now as they were five years
ago, he notes.
"At that age, it's almost always because of overuse,"
says Remia, who last year performed reconstructive surgery
on a 17-year-old pitcher from Key Largo.
The pitcher, Mike Arnold, missed his senior season
at Coral Shores High and is now trying to get his 90-mph
fastball back. He's still rehabbing, hoping to catch
a scout's eye.
Remia hears countless versions of the same story. At
10, a boy starts pitching and dominates the competition.
Because he loves baseball, he goes on to play in his
local all-star, or "travel" organization.
Maybe he plays in another league, too. He shakes off
what he thinks are minor aches and pains, but then it
hurts so much there is no way to shake it off. His arm
is shot.
"It's an epidemic," Remia says. "If
a kid has pain, and it's not going away, it's not normal."
Too many games
Usually children are trying to do more than their bodies
are capable of. The Physician and Sportsmedicine journal
says overuse injuries have replaced traumatic injuries
as the most common reasons children visit doctors with
a sports injury.
The biggest problems have been almost like a child's
version of repetitive-stress syndrome. Throwing a baseball
too much. Kicking, skating or jumping too much.
The doctors point to year-round sports -- be it too
many sports or too many games of one particular sport
-- as a contributor.
"They just never give their body an opportunity
to rest, and they get stress fractures," Sheinberg
says. "What gets frustrating is seeing the same
kids over and over. The kids who are real good athletes
are wanted by coaches of all the sports. It tips the
scale just enough."
Sheinberg says the other frustration comes when it's
time to heal: The kids just don't want to sit still.
"Almost all of the injuries require immobilization,
and when you're dealing with a child they have a hard
time getting better," he says. "They don't
get off their feet."
Says Hollywood Christian School softball player Katie
Ottens, who gritted through a damaged heel for 11 weeks
between her sophomore and junior years before having
surgery: "You have only a short time to play in
national tournaments and be seen. I didn't want to miss
that." Now a senior, she has earned a scholarship
to Baylor University.
Weighing the data
Because there is no central organization for youth
sports, documenting the increase in injuries involves
as many anecdotes as hard data. American Sports Data
Inc., which researches sports and fitness trends, says
"Children are introduced to sports at unprecedented
ages -- practices that may also contribute to rising
youth injury rates." It also implores the medical
community to conduct a national sports injury study.
What we know:
The Consumer Product Safety Commission says almost
4 million children from ages 5 to 16 sustained some
type of sports injury in 2002 that required a doctor's
visit, and other groups estimate that up to 8 million
more kids just shrug it off and play hurt. Those numbers
are about double of what they were 10 years ago, according
to the commission.
The National Youth Sports Safety Foundation, a nonprofit
group in Boston, provides the most-quoted estimate,
saying that about 12 million of the 40 million children
who participate in youth sports will have at least a
minor injury, such as tendinitis, during the year.
The Physician and Sportsmedicine estimated that 30
percent to 50 percent (3.6 million to 6 million) of
those are related to overuse. And this comes during
an era in youth sports where more children are branching
away to individual "extreme" sports, such
as skateboarding and mountain biking, which, by the
high-risk nature of falling, lend themselves to more
acute injuries.
Robin Varon, head of the rehab branch of Imperial Point
Medical Center in Fort Lauderdale, says, "You used
to see the injuries we see now in a little older age.
Kids are being pushed more and more. That's the natural
trend."
And it might be for nothing.
Georgia Tech sports medicine expert Jim Brown, in his
book, Sports Talent: How to Identify and Develop Outstanding
Athletes, writes: "Does a child have to be a star
at 8 to be a star at 18? No. Earlier is not necessarily
better in terms of sports-specific training. There is
plenty of evidence to show that the real athletes kick
in at age 13 or 14."
Maintaining the body
Alex Leamy's soccer team came all the way from Ohio
to compete in the Orange Classic International Girls
Soccer Tournament in Plantation, so she isn't going
to let a mildly sprained ankle stop her.
She tapes it herself before running out to the field
to play her fifth game in four days. It's the Cincinnati
squad's third big trip since November. They've also
been to Bethesda, Md., and Raleigh, N.C.
"I just want to keep playing," says Leamy,
16, and her teammates around her nod. They'd do the
same thing themselves.
Their coach, Kristin DePlatchett, says she encourages
the players to treat their minor injuries. Learning
that responsibility helps when they play at higher levels.
"The idea is to keep the little things from turning
into big things," she says. "They have to
truly rest when they're supposed to rest."
Injury prevention has also improved, she says. Girls
now lift weights to strengthen leg muscles -- and lessen
their chances of a knee ligament injury.
It's vital the girls learn body maintenance now, says
DePlatchett, who played at the University of North Carolina
and then professionally.
"They're all relatively healthy right now,"
she says. "But at the college level, with training
every day, there are chronic knee issues and more injuries."
Using pitch counts
Youth baseball organizations are taking a more nurturing
approach toward the tender arms of young pitchers. Some
focus on pre-workout stretches, "long-toss"
workouts and pitching mechanics.
And some are even counting pitches thrown, rather than
innings, to determine when a pitcher should rest. In
Little League, for example, 11- and 12-year-olds who
throw four or more innings must have three days of rest
before pitching again. Boca Raton Youth Baseball last
year required coaches to count pitches and record them
on a pitching log. They will require it again when the
season starts this month.
"The children aren't going to say `My arm hurts,
take me out,'" says league president Laura Kaufman.
"They want to stay in the game. It's easy, especially
in the lower levels, for them to throw 100 pitches and
not come near their inning count."
She's also encouraging the parents, rather than the
coaches, to count pitches, because often a child will
participate in a second league -- and continue throwing.
"If they go off to a different league and throw
that many pitches again, it doesn't work," she
says.
The prognosis
The good news is that overuse sports injuries are preventable.
But to merely point a finger at parents and coaches
and demand that they back off is an oversimplified solution.
The one-sport athlete is here to stay, bringing the
disappearance of the benefits of built-in muscle-group
rest as a teen rotates from, say, winter basketball
to spring baseball. Meanwhile, not only have the unstructured
backyard games diminished -- where children who got
tired simply stopped playing -- but year-round travel
leagues for every sport imaginable continue to flourish,
and are more ingrained than ever in youth sports culture.
Future athletes can view the current sore-armed pitchers
and limping soccer players as a cautionary tale, and
youth sports coaches can employ more stretches and injury-prevention
techniques to their practices each season. And perhaps
everyone can watch a little more carefully for telltale
signs of overuse and evaluate a child at the first sign
of fatigue.
Further, everyone can ditch the macho glorification
of "playing hurt" seen in pro sports, because,
after all, the pros are out there for cash -- and the
children for fun. But they can certainly adopt another
lesson from the pros.
Recognize that every sport has an off-season, a time
for even the most dedicated athletes to put their feet
up, have fun or just take a deep breath before priming
themselves for the next Opening Day.
QUESTIONS TO ASK AFTER A SPORTS INJURY
Was there a change in training intensity, frequency,
or duration?
Was a new technique or piece of equipment introduced?
Is the athlete involved in other activities such as
resistance training or physical education classes that
could have contributed to the injury?
Has there been a similar injury in the past, and does
the patient have a history of other overuse injuries?
How were past injuries treated?
SOURCE: The Physician and Sportsmedicine Journal
Copyright © 2004, South Florida Sun-Sentinel
|