SI article on youth sports is a must-read
for parents
Nov 20, 2003
Asking a pre-teen to play nothing
but baseball or soccer year round is doing him or her
a disservice.
This Week Columbus Newspaper
I was waiting in the doctor's office the other day, looking
for something to read and was faced with two choices --
a six-week-old Sports Illustrated I'd already seen and
an equally out-of-date U.S. News & World Report.
I opted for the Oct. 6 edition of Sports Illustrated.
I subscribe, so I have the issue at home. But there
was a tease on the cover for a story I'd been meaning
to read: "The American Athlete Age 10 - Time of
Their Lives or Too Much, Too Soon"
I remember seeing the article when I was leafing through
my copy at home. My son, Max, was about to turn 10,
so I had been meaning to read it. But the story and
sidebars run for 17 pages in the magazine, so reading
it had become one of those things I was going to do
"when I had the time."
But like most things on that list, reading a 17-page
Sports Illustrated article kept falling further and
further below mowing the lawn, folding laundry and trying
to keep the children from strangling each other. But
in the peace of the doctor's waiting room, I managed
to get to it. Once I started, I couldn't put the magazine
down.
If you have children, boys or girls, between the ages
of 8 and 12, you need to find a copy of this article
and read it. It details a lot of the things we're doing
right by our children and some of the things we're doing
wrong.
It speaks to how 10 years old is the age when children
are like sponges. They can absorb information like they
couldn't only a year or two before. But the hormones
and moodiness of adolescence haven't kicked in yet.
According to the article, 10-year-olds love "to
be praised; to be asked their opinion and tell what
they know; to belong, be it to clubs or teams or other
groups; and to hear true stories, not just made-up ones."
To use a pseudo-word that's become commonplace in sports,
they're coachable.
"Sports offer many of the things that 10-year-olds
crave. Teams are clubs; victories and defeats are real,
not made up; and the rules are presumably applied evenly,"
the writer, Alexander Wolff, continues.
The article was especially interesting to me. Max is
everything Wolff describes. He loves sports -- the camaraderie
and the competition, the thrill of victory and the agony
of defeat. He loves to talk about them as much as he
loves playing them.
It's the thing we have most in common. When I was his
age, I was playing basketball in the winter, baseball
in the spring and football in the fall. When I wasn't
playing for an organized team, there were pick-up games
in the park.
That interest didn't wane as I got older. It ballooned.
I went from playing sports to reading about them to
eventually writing about them. I was the sports editor
of the newspapers in high school and college. And my
first jobs out of college were as sports writers.
Max seems to share those passions. It seems fitting
that he was born during the Game 4 of the 1993 World
Series. The Blue Jays beat the Phillies 15-14 in the
highest scoring game in World Series history. My favorite
photograph of myself shows Max and I watching the end
of the game in the hospital room when he was half an
hour old.
I've tried not to push Max into sports. My parents
didn't push me, I found them on my own. But the temptation
is often overwhelming. Since his first season of T-ball
at 5, I've been an assistant coach on each of Max's
teams. I often wonder if that's a good thing. I want
to be involved, but I also want those teams to be his,
not mine.
The Sports Illustrated article chronicles not only
what's right with the American athlete at age 10, but
what we're often doing wrong. Wolff describes the pressure
that's already being put on kids to specialize. While
I played basketball, football and baseball, kids today,
especially the most gifted athletes, are often asked
to play one sport year round. Basketball-football-baseball
has become basketball-basketball-basketball or soccer-soccer-soccer.
Wolff points out that many experts say there's no need
for a child to choose a sport to the exclusion of others
that early. In junior high, Michael Jordan was a better
football and baseball player than a basketball player.
Kids don't all mature at the same rate and, at 10, it's
impossible to tell which ones are going to be the best
players and at which sports.
Asking a pre-teen to play nothing but baseball or soccer
year round is doing him or her a disservice. They may
not find the sport they're going to have a real talent
or passion for. Just because a soccer player is faster
than her peers and scores four goals per game at 10,
doesn't mean mean she should never dribble a basketball.
The article contains a sidebar about a 10-year-old
from Alabama who played in 127 baseball games in 2001,
90 of them with a team based a two-hour, 45-minute drive
from his house. Don't think he's going to burn out on
baseball, I have two words for you: Todd Marinovich.
If you don't know who he is (or was), look it up.
I've been guilty of some of that myself. Max is not
big to begin with. And because he started kindergarten
in California as a four-year-old, he's a fifth-grader
who only turned 10 a month ago. Many of his classmates
are a full year older and a foot taller. He's made it
through the third- and fourth-grade seasons without
scoring a point.
He gets frustrated, but always plays hard. This year
before the sign-ups, I asked if he was sure he wanted
to play. Maybe he should just concentrate on baseball,
I said. Thankfully, Max said no. He wanted to play basketball
again.
He still may become a good basketball player. Even
if he doesn't, Max is a very good teammate. He's giving
as much as he's getting from sports.
Max played only one year of soccer and never really
took to it. But he's been playing baseball, which is
played as much with your head as with your body, since
kindergarten. This year, for the first time, he played
fall baseball. He had a great time, but that's as specialized
as he's going to get for a while.
His sister, Madison, is seven. So far, she's shown
very little interest in team sports. She likes gymnastics
and is a good swimmer for her age. But the best thing
I can do is expose her to many things and let her find
her own passion. And she will. It may not be sports.
It may be the violin, the stage, computers or even,
God forbid, cheerleading. Soon, we'll start to find
out.
Like I said, if you have a child at or around 10 years
of age, you need to read that article. As far as I can
tell, it's no longer available online. So you'll have
to track down the back issue. You can always look at
your doctor's office.
|