Fingerprints on the ballfield
Dec 23, 2003
SAFETY: After a molester becomes
a coach, parents say background checks should be mandatory.
By SANDRA STOKLEY / The Press-Enterprise
RUBIDOUX - Not long after Adolph Ganion III's arrest
in October on suspicion of child molestation, Rubidoux
resident Margie Loya had a heart-to-heart talk with
her 13-year-old son.
"It was hard," Loya said, as she sat in the
stands of Veterans Memorial Park on a blustery November
afternoon. "I didn't even know how to ask him."
It was a scene played out over and over as worried
parents of Jurupa National Little League players took
their children aside and asked about inappropriate behavior
during the time they were coached by Ganion - who police
say used the name Al Humphrey.
Former Little League coach Adolph Ganion III has been
charged with child molestation.
Although her son said nothing had happened, the experience
has left Loya and other parents shaken and adamant that
Little League needs to mandate the fingerprinting of
all volunteers for the sake of the children.
"The parents are all concerned," Loya said.
"We've got to be more careful."
In the case of Jurupa National and other youth sports
leagues that play on Jurupa-area fields, the decision
to mandate fingerprinting has already been made for
them.
On Dec. 11 the Jurupa Area Recreation and Park District
board of directors voted to require fingerprinting of
all volunteers who work with local youth sports leagues
such as Little League and AYSO.
But Little League officials say that the cost of fingerprinting
the 1.5 million volunteers that form the backbone of
Little League Baseball is financially prohibitive and
could confer a false sense of security.
While fingerprinting would have turned up Ganion's
criminal record involving children - which authorities
say stretches back to 1978 - such a procedure would
do nothing to stop a sexual predator who has no record.
This year, Little League began requiring a check of
each state's sexual offender registry for every volunteer.
But that requirement came with a warning, according
to Little League spokesman Lance Van Auken.
"We've told our leagues from the start that this
can't be seen as a panacea," Van Auken said. "They
have to be vigilant for signs of a sex offender."
Guidelines posted
Little League has posted guidelines for spotting a
potential child molester. Among them: providing unwarranted
trips, displaying excessive interest in children, getting
along with children better than adults.
It remains unclear whether Jurupa National Little League
ever did any type of background check on any of its
volunteers, includingHumphrey.
"He was a good coach," said parent Ignacio
Gonzalez. "He was patient, knowledgeable and didn't
yell at the kids. He bought them drinks and snacks."
But other parents said they had concerns.When they
asked board President Butch Guzman and other board members
whether Humphrey had been fingerprinted, they were told
there was no money.
Guzman and Vice President Jesse Vasquez have declined
comment on anything having to do with Humphrey. Van
Auken said the matter is under investigation.
A check of Los Angeles County court records shows that
in 1977 Adolph Ganion III was charged with six counts
of lewd and lascivious acts involving six boys, all
of them 11 and 12 years old. He pleaded guilty to three
counts and was placed on four years' probation.
A condition of probation barred him from ever coaching
any sports activity involving children.
Ten years later, in 1987, Ganion was charged with molesting
three boys - two 6-year-olds and a 2-year-old.
Charges involving the toddler were ultimately dismissed
and Ganion pleaded no contest to two counts of lewd
and lascivious acts with a child and one count of sodomy
of a person under 14.
He was sentenced to 15 years in state prison.
Familiar face
Accusations of child molestation and Ganion's use of
another name came to light after a resident saw his
face in the Megan's Law database, said Deputy Dennis
Gutierrez, a Riverside County Sheriff's Department spokesman.
The resident recognized Ganion as the person known
in the Jurupa area as Al Humphrey and alerted law enforcement.
During the subsequent investigation, several children
came forward and accused Ganion of molestation.
Ganion has been charged with 14 felony counts alleging
lewd and lascivious acts against children. If convicted
on all counts, he faces a sentence of life in prison.
Ganion, who remains jailed at Robert Presley Detention
Center, has entered a plea of not guilty.
Millions of volunteers
The challenge of requiring fingerprinting for everyone
involved in youth sports activities becomes apparent
in light of the sheer numbers of children and volunteers
involved.
According to a 2001 study of the National Council of
Youth Sports, every year an estimated 38 million youngsters
in the United States participate in some type of sport
be it baseball, soccer, hockey, basketball or football.
They are coached by millions of volunteers.
According to Van Auken, the cost of fingerprinting
varies widely from state to state.
The Riverside Police Department charges $10 per set
of prints sent to the California Department of Justice,
according to Officer Felix Medina. The state charges
$32 to run the prints and a check of the FBI database
costs an additional $24.
But money should not be an issue in California, said
Santa Ana Attorney Thomas Cifarelli, who sued Little
League Baseball in 2000 on behalf of several children
victimized by Norman Watson.
Watson was a convicted child molester who coached for
a number of years for East Baseline Little League in
the San Bernardino County city of Highland. He pleaded
guilty to 39 counts of child-related sex offenses in
1998 and received an 84-year-sentence.
Since the 1980s, California law allows for no-cost
fingerprint checks for nonprofit organizations such
as Little League, Cifarelli said.
Background check regulations differ from sport to sport.
AYSO performs "targeted" checks.
Pony Baseball/Softball recommends background checks
but has no requirements. Riverside County Deputy District
Attorney Kelly Hansen, who is prosecuting Ganion, said
he believes strongly that a thorough background check
should be done on anyone working with children, no matter
the cost.
"I think most parents would be willing pay (an
extra cost)," Hansen said. "I don't think
money should ever be the issue in determining if our
kids are safe."
|